“Jill I love you and I truly do wanna be with you. This new found love for you is very strong to say the least. You are bar none the best sister. For what it’s worth, right now, I don’t envision myself with anyone else. I wanna be with you,” Jeff said.
“You wanna start dating now and be my boyfriend?” I asked.
“Is it weird to date your sister?” Jeff asked.
“Just don’t expect to get lucky after every date. Maybe every now and then, but that’s it,” I replied.
Then we both laughed.
“What if we just wanna do it? Do we always have to go on a date first?” Jeff asked.
“We’ll see. But are you ready for this? This is an incestuous relationship and completely uncharted waters for both of us,” I replied.
Then he gave me another kiss.
“Never more ready my lady. I just want you, not anyone else in the world, I swear,” Jeff said.
“Not even Jessica?” I asked.
“Not even her. She is sexy as you said, but she is just a friend now. Maybe a close friend, but still just a friend. You are the only one I wanna see naked,” Jeff replied.
Then I laughed with him, we had some chemistry.
“Truth or dare?” I asked.
“Truth,” Jeff replied.
“Would you really be OK if you just had sex with your sister for the rest of your life?” I asked.
“Absolutely,” Jeff replied.
So then we kissed again. A few weeks went by, we were getting along great. We had sex quite a few times. Jessica never joined in again, but she was still around. We still weren’t sleeping together though. I guess we just didn’t feel up to it yet. But that’s definitely something you notice. We were sitting on the couch as were holding hands one Saturday afternoon.
“Truth or dare?” Jeff asked.
“Truth,” I replied.
“Are you gonna hog the covers when we sleep together?” Jeff asked.
“Would that be a deal breaker if I did?” I asked.
Then he laid down and pulled me down on top of him with my back to his stomach.
“No, I can’t say it would be. But you are one difficult woman though,” Jeff replied.
“And how do figure that?” I asked.
“Well can I ask you, how long have you felt this way about me?” Jeff asked.
I couldn’t pinpoint it to a specific time.
“Well I guess before mom and dad died, you always took care of me. And we weren’t together. So I guess it was little by little for awhile, then mom and dad died. And I guess aside from Jessica, you were really there for me. We were there for each other. So the pieces were there and they slowly came together. I can’t say I’m sorry this happened though,” I replied.
“Do you think we’re ready to start sleeping together? I know we’re having sex, but what do you think?” Jeff asked.
Truth be told I wasn’t sure. But I knew I loved him and he loved me. This wasn’t just lust we had for each other.
“Well, I think we’re ready. If for some odd reason it doesn’t work, then we can stop and go back to separate beds I guess,” I replied.
“OK then. But if you are having doubts then tell me now,” Jeff said.
“None,” I replied as I gave him a kiss.
So far our relationship was going quite well despite the way it happened. But the next thing he said I don’t think I expected at all.
“I’ve been meaning to talk to you about something sis. If it’s just way too soon to even talk about it, tell me. But do you wanna have a baby with me?” Jeff asked.
He was right, it was too soon to be talking about that.
“Well I’m thrilled you wanna have a baby with me. But yes it is too soon to be talking about it. Our relationship is only a few weeks old now. I’m not saying a baby would plague our relationship right now, but maybe we’re just not ready to jump off that bridge just yet. We’re just now talking about sleeping together, maybe we should take it a little slow. But I’ll tell you this, I do want a baby with you sooner or later,” I said.
“Well, I wasn’t about to suggest we try it now. But if worse comes to worse and something does happen, I think it’d be nice if we at least talked about it,” Jeff replied.
He was right. If something did happen we should at least have some plan. But I don’t think we were ready to jump off that bridge. So we tabled that for the time being. Over the weeks Jessica did come over from time to time. But I was worried about something though. He was still eyeballing her ass when she was over later that day.
“Well, how has the relationship been?” Jessica asked.
“Good. We’re getting along great. About a month ago now we started sleeping together. But she does hog the covers though,” Jeff replied.
“Somehow I can believe that. She always was a little greedy,” Jessica said.
“Be nice. I know I’m a little greedy, but you don’t have to gang up on me though,” I replied.
Then they both gave me a hug.
“We know, we’re just giving you a hard time,” Jeff said.
“I know. But still you are both mean,” I replied.
“Yeah we are. I’m gonna go to the bathroom real quick,” Jessica said.
Then she got up and walked out of the room and to the bathroom. But his eyes were still on her ass.
“Seriously Jeff, I let it go of it for awhile, now I think it could be getting on my nerves. I know she is very cute and sexy, but you need to quit eyeballing her ass,” I said.
I think he was ashamed. This was like the 6th time I had to say something to him.
“I’m sorry sweetheart. I’m just still attracted to her. I don’t know what else to say,” Jeff replied.
So after that, things were better a little better with that. He stopped looking at her ass when she was around. So then another couple weeks later, she was over once again. I loved her like a sister, but it seemed to be getting a little annoying how much she was over with us. We just started our relationship, and maybe it wasn’t for the best that she was over all the time. Jeff was out shopping for us.
“I’m driving you crazy being over here all the time, aren’t I?” Jessica asked.
“Well maybe a little. I mean you are my best friend, don’t get me wrong. But maybe you are here a little too much. And, I know Jeff is still attracted to you. Not that I truly think anything will happen. But I really want my relationship to work. And right now I think we just need more time alone,” I replied.
She understood. She saw we had some chemistry and she didn’t wanna mess it up for us.
“OK I hear you. I’ll try and limit my visits here. I guess I’m just really happy for you,” Jessica said.
“Well thank you for understanding,” I replied.
Then we gave each other a hug as Jeff got back.
“Hey get a room,” Jeff said.
“You are funny,” I replied.
“Well I’m gonna head out. I might call you in a couple days,” Jessica said.
“Are you sure, you don’t gotta leave just yet,” Jeff replied.
“I got things to do. But I’ll see you later,” Jessica said.
“OK,” Jeff replied.
Then she left and once again as she left I caught Jeff checking out her butt.
“Come on Jeff, again?” I asked.
“I’m sorry Jill,” Jeff replied.
“You are sorry? You’ve only said sorry like what 10 times now? What do I have to do to get you to stop looking at her ass?” I asked.
I could tell he felt bad. But I saw that before though.
“I don’t know sweetie. Maybe we shouldn’t have had that threesome,” Jeff replied.
“Damn right. Now really, what the fuck? Don’t you wanna be with me? I thought you said you’d do your best not to break my heart?” I asked.
Then he came towards me and kissed me.
“Of course I wanna be with you, I love you,” Jeff replied.
“Then why are you still eyeballing her ass?” I asked.
He didn’t know what to say. And he just saw me really pissed.
“I’m gonna go to my room, and you figure out who you wanna be with,” I said.
Then I walked very angrily to the bedroom. I shut and locked the door. Then of course he came over to the door and started knocking.
“Jill, I swear to you that I wanna be with you. You are the best woman that I have ever been with. I wanna spend the rest of my life with you no matter what. Eventually I would love to get you pregnant. Then we can be a family,” Jeff said.
He tried opening the door, but it was locked.
“Please open the door angel. I will never break your heart. It was just harmless looking,” Jeff said.
“No, you have been looking at her a lot lately,” I replied.
Then he started talking in a sad tone.
“I promise you I will never ever stop loving you,” Jeff said.
Then I opened the door.
“Then why would you stare at her ass when you know how it makes me feel?” I asked as we both started sparking a few tears.
“I don’t know. But I wanna be with you, I swear,” Jeff replied.
“Then why Jeff?!” I Yelled.
Then he just stood there and just had this clueless look on his face. He had nothing he could say to make this better.
“Will I lose you over this?” Jeff asked.
“I don’t know. But it seems you have a thing for her. So just go figure it out,” I replied.
Then I went back in the room and slammed the door. I think we both felt a little heart broken. So I stayed in there and he stayed in the living room for a few hours. I didn’t know what to think. I knew he loved me, but still how could be really justify him eyeballing her ass? Then I came out of the room and into the living room. I was still shedding a few tears, as was he. I sat down with him and gave him a hug.
“I don’t wanna fight. But I still feel a little betrayed I guess,” I said.
“Well I love you Jill. Now more than ever. I’m so sorry. Nothing will ever happen between Jessica and I,” Jeff replied.
“Did you mean everything you said?” I asked.
“Yes, 100%,” Jeff replied.
“Then truth or dare?” I asked.
“Dare,” Jeff replied.
“Make love to me,” I said as I took a birth control pill
“Now?” Jeff asked.
“Show me how much you love me,” I replied.
Then we started making out a bit as I leaned down. Well we had our first fight. It couldn’t be avoided forever. He started undoing my pants and pulled them down along with my underwear as he got down on his knees. I undid his pants and pulled them down too as he stood up. Then I laid down and he got on top of me as he inserted his dick onto me.
“I love you Jill, don’t forget that,” Jeff said.
“I love you too Jeff. I really don’t wanna lose you either,” I replied.
Then we kissed each other as he began thrusting his dick in and out of me. But I was still sparking some tears though. But he knew one of my weaknesses though. He started licking my nipples.
“You know I like that,” I said.
“And your point is?” Jeff asked.
He began grabbing my boobs as well. He shook them a bit too for a minute. Then he leaned down and began kissing me. I felt my nice boobs pressing onto him as he got a little rough with me.
“Oh fuck Jeff. That’s good. Keep jamming your dick inside me deep. Show me that you just wanna fuck me, not her,” I said.
“I do sis, I just wanna fuck you and no one else,” Jeff replied.
Then he pulled out and he sat down on his butt. Then I got on top of him reverse cowgirl style. He put his hands onto my butt as I was bouncing up and down. I started moaning once again.
“Shit Jeff. You really got a thing for me,” I said.
He laughed a little.
“You could say that Jill,” Jeff replied.
As I was bouncing the pleasure just intensified more and more. My boobs were shaking nonstop and we were having great make up sex. He put one of his hands onto my pussy and began rubbing it a bit. Then made me moan even more.
“Fuck Jeff. Yes fuck me with your fingers and your dick. Do it like that,” I said.
Then a couple minutes later, I got up and ripped the condom off. I took his dick in my mouth. I started to deep throat him and he put his hands onto my head. He loved my blow jobs.
“Oh shit Jill, damn that feels good,” Jeff said.
I went down as far as I could on him. I started going up and down rather quickly too. He put his hands onto my forehead and noticed once again that I was getting sweaty.
“Slow down a little sis, you don’t wanna completely tire yourself out,” Jeff said.
“I won’t, I promise, I just wanna make love to you,” I replied.
Then I sucked on his dick really passionately. I made the slurping sounds too. He was starting to moan a great deal.
“Oh shit Jill, you are gonna make me cum now,” Jeff said.
Then I stroked his dick once again and made him cum a great deal. Then we both laid down and cuddled on the couch with him laying his head on my boobs. He told me he loved me numerous times and assured me I was the one he wanted to be with.
“I just want you Jill. No one else, I swear it to you. Now and absolutely forever Jill. Please don’t ever think different,” Jeff said.
Then we kissed again as he began pinching my nipples. That he made me moan some more. I knew he loved me and the make up sex was good and didn’t even have to last very long either.
“Well, I guess we did have to have our first fight as boyfriend and girlfriend sooner or later,” I said.
“But we got through it. We still love each other very much. We can’t deny that we have feelings about things. They are gonna come out sooner or later. We can’t help it,” Jeff replied.
“Well, you are right about that. I know you are a guy, and wouldn’t cheat on me. But maybe it just ticked me off that much right then. I don’t know. But I know I love you more than a brother and I never wanna lose you either Jeff. I could never stomach it,” I said.
Then he leaned up and gave me a very passionate kiss.
“You know what? I love you too Jill. Let me show you just how much,” Jeff said as he pulled out a small box.
I couldn’t what he was doing honestly.
“I know we’ve only been dating a couple months now, but I know we both wanna make this last forever. I know I wanna do this, I don’t feel obligated at all. So truth or dare?” Jeff asked.
“Truth,” I replied.
“Jill Swanson will you marry me?” Jeff asked as he showed me a ring.
Via: https://www.lushstories.com/stories/incest-fantasy/truth-or-dare-brother-3
